Are crowds always wise: qualifying your crowd
Stumble It!The ever thoughtful David Pollard has an excellent article on the Wisdom of Crowds versus the Wisdom of Witch Doctors (Consultants and Senior Management) and how to tell the difference. By Paul Sweeney.
In the article Pollard outlines where crowds and experts might be best suited to particular types of problems, or stages of problem. All in all, pretty standard mangement theory.
What has changed over the years is our ability to "source crowds", poll opinion, and gather feedback.
For me one of the key questions arising from this article is "how can companies build qualified crowds", and in fact, is this capability in itself an key organisational competence?
Given that many of today’s Web 2.0 companies depend upon rapid development and feedback cycles from early adopters how do they know whether their 'crowds' are representative of the requirements of the vast majority of their actual enduser target audiences?
Perhaps we should develop tools to profile our 'crowd" before we put down some baseline strategic assumptions about our products or services.
In many ways we, as management and as companies, have the world ‘pre-interpreted’ and ‘pre-digested’ for us by our own histories, our teams experiences, and many other structural aspects of organisational behavour.
Perhaps in the "open world" of the internet, many companies and teams are unwittingly singing to a choir of their own choosing?
Paul Sweeney is European Marketing Director at voicesage and blogs at YOU'VE BEEN NOTICED
Tags: web2.0, wisdom of crowds
Digg | 
del.icio.us | 
Reddit | 
Yahoo! | 
Add to my favourites
Bioteams Books Reviews
Mobile business applications framework
In a just published book Work Goes Mobile by Michael Lattanzi, Antti Korhonen and Vishy Gopalakrishnan, authors of Nokia’s mobility master plan, propose a very useful application profiling scheme to establish the degree to which a business could exploit mobile technologies in their broadest sense. This approach would also be very useful for establishing the support requirements for virtually networked teams.
Buy it now from:
Amazon.Com
Amazon.Co.UK
Related News & Media Articles
Developing computer immune systems using natures models
THE way the body's immune system responds when its cells are under attack has inspired a new way of protecting computer networks from viruses and hackers according to an article in the NewScientist.com news service, 20 May 2006
New bioteams audio-visual presentation released
"Fascinating lessons we can very readily learn from the most successful living systems on the key characteristics needed to operate a highly effective organisational team”. I am delighted to announce that, in collaboration with Robin Good, I have developed a new audio-visual presentation entitled "How to fix the three killer problems in your teams without any extra technology".
Home based virtual call centre trend
Home-shoring is replacing off-shoring
Matt Keating, writing in Phone home for The Guardian (Saturday October 15), reports that “Virtual call centres” (aka home-shoring) where staff work from home over the web can save employers significant infrastructure and accommodation costs and also keep workers happier.He also notes some of the management challenges in keeping the remote workers connected with their employers.
Leave a comment