Nature's best cooperation strategy revealed

Two collaboration strategies, Tit-For-Tat (TFT) and Win-Stay,Lose-Shift (WSLS), out-perform all others in evolution. In a live webstream from the Royal Society in London Professor Martin Nowak of Harvard University explains why.


Cooperation is neither rational not fair but it works!

In a live webstream from the Royal Society in London on Tuesday 3 May 2005 Professor Martin Nowak of Harvard University explained "How cooperation evolves in biology and life?"

To watch a recording of the webstream

Professor Nowak addressed the question using evolutionary game theory supported by experimental observations of different biological systems.

What does it mean for bioteams?

Selfishness does not work in long run

As a member of a team you choose how you will behave.

Rationally speaking the best strategy is actually not to cooperate - you will always do better in the short-term if you act in pure self-interest.

However, over the longer term, the other team members will start to retaliate against you and everyone, you included, starts to lose out.

Naiveity fails too

You could instead try "unconditional cooperation" - however all the evidence shows you will inevitably be exploited over the long-run.

Tit for Tat is good

It turns out that the best overall strategy for cooperation is "Tit-for-Tat" (TFT).

TFT starts cooperatively but if the other person behaves non-cooperatively you do likewise but then immediately forgive and go back to cooperating.

Win-Stay, Lose-Shift is better

However in the real world TFT has one very big weakness.

If a mistake happens and an action is wrongly taken or even perceived as non-cooperative then the other person will retaliate.

Thus a mistake in TFT starts a whole spiral of counter-retaliation which wipes out the benefits of cooperation.

A better overall cooperation strategy in an environment where mistakes can be made is "Win-Stay, Lose-Shift" (WSLS).

WSLS means that if what you are doing is working then continue to do it but if is not working then immediately change it.

(Nowak also points out that WSLS also has the benefit(?) of allowing you to exploit "unconditional cooperators" aka "suckers").

Professor Nowak shows how different cooperation stategies evolve and compete with each other within a population or a team.

For example a "cluster" of Tit for Tat players will grow and eventually convert other non-cooperative players to TFT.

Interestingly the research and experimental evidence in biology shows that if more than three quarters (actually 74%) of a population are using non-cooperative strategies then the team is beyond cooperation and is destined to stay in destructive behaviour and its consequences.

(In human biology this is what a disease like cancer looks like from the viewpoint of "cooperation").

The bottom line for bioteams is this:

In a bioteam you need to choose your cooperation strategy carefully.

In the long run cooperation works out best for everybody but needs to be carefully incubated.

Different strategies are appropriate at different stages of the team.

Those team members who adopt either a totally selfish or an overly altruistic strategy will eventually turn out to be losers individually and bring collective damage to their teams.

Comments (0)| Related (3) |

Print this article


Bioteams Books Reviews

Self managed teams 101

Self managed teams 101

Grass Roots Management shows you how to grow initiative and responsibility in all your people. It might not appeal to purists, but using the narrative of a business based on a garden open to the public the author gives a very simple, accessible and readable account of 'self-managed teams'.

Buy it now from:


continue reading

Click here to check all Bioteams book reviews

Ken's LinkedIn Profile

Follow Ken's Blogs

NASA Widget2_160x40.jpg


Featured Categories

Trending Topics

agility analytics ants autopoiesis bees biomimicry bioteaming bioteams change management collaboration Collaboration collective intelligence community complex systems dashboards digital dashboards ecosystems excel experiential learning flock games high-performing teams HPT innovation leadership learning meetings mobile phones organizational teams penguins pheromones self-managed teams serious games simulators social media Social Networks social networks social software swarm swarm intelligence swarmteams teams teamwork The Networked Enterprise tit for tat VEN videos virtual communities virtual enterprise virtual enterprise networks virtual teams visualization web2.0 wisdom of crowds

Click for more...

Featured Article

Team joining hands

The secret DNA of high-performing virtual teams

Bioteaming – the secret to high-performing, self-organising, virtually networked teams... more

Locations of visitors to this page

Bioteams iphone app
Bioteams android app


Bioteams Lite


Latest Full Articles

Bioteams Assessor - Instantly check how good your team is?
BioScore Calculator – Instantly see if you need Bioteams
Discover Bioteams principles Yourself via Action Learning

Bioteams Manifesto

Communities and Networks Connection

Bioteams Ice-Breaker Zone

Only Fools and Horses Video Clip Funny Team Collaboration Video Dilbert Mission Statement Generator Ali G Video Funny Red Dwarf Video  FatherTed  Pixar

News Feed

Sign up for RSS   RSS Feed Subscription
        (What's RSS?)

10 Most popular posts

Recent posts


Download Browsealoud